Text 1: Architect Prof. Ana Müller champions adaptive reuse. "Converting old factories and warehouses into housing preserves character while meeting urban needs," Müller writes. "These buildings offer unique spaces impossible to replicate in new construction."
Text 2: Developer James Chen prefers new construction. "Historic buildings often require expensive retrofitting for modern codes," Chen notes. "New construction can be designed for current needs from the start, with superior energy efficiency and accessibility."
How does Chen's perspective in Text 2 challenge Müller's advocacy in Text 1?
By denying that old buildings have any aesthetic value
By emphasizing practical and efficiency advantages of purpose-built structures
By arguing that cities have no housing needs
By claiming historic preservation is illegal
Correct Answer: B
Choice B is the correct answer. Chen challenges adaptive reuse on practical grounds: retrofitting costs, code compliance, efficiency. He argues new construction is more practical.
- Evidence: Chen cites "expensive retrofitting" and "superior energy efficiency."
- Reasoning: He counters character with practicality.
- Conclusion: Chen emphasizes pragmatic advantages Müller downplays.
Choice A is incorrect because Chen doesn't deny aesthetic value. Choice C is incorrect because both acknowledge housing needs. Choice D is incorrect because legality isn't discussed.